Sports Bra Shopping – The Pain Points and How to Beat Them

Buying a new sports bra sounds simple enough. But if you’ve ever left a fitting room sweaty, frustrated, and questioning life choices, you know it’s a whole experience. Let’s break down the most common pain points women face when hunting for that perfect fit — and, more importantly, how to fix them so you can feel supported, comfortable, and ready to take on anything.

Straps Digging into Shoulders

You know that feeling — like your bra is trying to carve a permanent groove into your shoulders. Ouch.

Solution:
Look for wider, padded straps that help spread the weight of your bust more evenly. Adjustable straps are a must — they let you tweak the fit to suit your body, not some mythical “standard size” woman.

Tight Band Around Ribs

The band should support you, not squeeze you into submission like a Victorian corset.

Solution:
When trying on, you should be able to fit two fingers comfortably under the band. It should feel firm but allow you to breathe and move easily. If the band digs in or leaves deep marks, size up or opt for a bra with a broader band for better pressure distribution.

Cup Spillage or Overflow

Hello, quad-boob! If your breasts are spilling out the sides or top, the cup size is too small.

Solution:
Size up in the cup. You want complete containment with no overflow. Full-coverage styles or bras with moulded cups can offer extra control and a smoother silhouette under clothes.

Woman adjusting her sports bra strap.

Chafing and Irritation

There’s nothing quite like the sting of sweaty, chafed skin after a workout. Lovely.

Solution:
Choose bras with flat seams or seamless construction to minimize friction. Look for soft, moisture-wicking fabrics that draw sweat away from the skin. Bonus tip: a little dab of anti-chafe balm under your arms or below the bust can work wonders on long training days.

Band Riding Up

If your band keeps riding up your back, it’s waving a red flag that it’s too loose.

Solution:
Try a smaller band size. Always fit your bra on the loosest hook when new — this allows room to tighten it as the elastic naturally relaxes over time.

Lack of Support

If you feel like you’re wearing a “fashion bra” instead of a “sports bra,” it’s not going to cut it.

Solution:
Look for bras labeled specifically for high or extreme impact if you’re running, jumping, or doing dynamic workouts. Compression and encapsulation styles offer maximum support without feeling like body armour.

Difficulty Putting On/Taking Off

Wrestling yourself in and out of a sweaty sports bra is practically a workout on its own.

Solution:
Front-closure styles save the day. Or look for bras with a back closure and adjustable straps so you can open things up rather than resort to sweaty gymnastics.

Uncomfortable Underwire

Underwire can either be your best friend or your worst enemy. If it digs, pokes, or rubs, you’ll want to scream halfway through your workout.

Solution:
Look for sports bras with flexible underwires that are padded and fully encased. If underwires just aren’t for you, newer wire-free designs can still offer outstanding support without any of the stabby drama.

Bounce and Movement

The infamous “bounce test” isn’t just for fun — it’s crucial. If things are moving too much, you’ll feel it (and regret it).

Solution:
Jump, jog, and twist in the fitting room. Your breasts should feel supported but not flattened into pancakes. A good sports bra locks everything down without making you feel like you can’t breathe.

Incorrect Sizing

The biggest pain point of all? Wearing the wrong size without even realising it.

Solution:
Get professionally fitted — yes, even if it’s been years. Weight changes, hormonal shifts, pregnancy, or just aging can all affect your breast size and shape. Even a quick re-measure at home with a soft tape can make a huge difference.

Final Thoughts

Sports bra shopping can definitely throw a few curveballs your way, but knowing the common pain points — and how to fix them — turns you into a savvy, supported shopper. Don’t settle for straps that dig, cups that spill, or bands that ride up. Take your time, try different styles, and remember: you deserve a bra that fits beautifully, supports fully, and feels so good you almost forget you’re wearing it.

Because your body deserves the best — during every run, stretch, lift, and downward dog.

Yours in support,

Amy x

Amy Jaffers - Sports Bra Expert

Amy Jaffers

Amy is the face behind Sports Bras Direct, Australia’s largest sports bra website. She's a mother of two, outdoors lover and sports bra expert. Her life mission is to help active women get the support they need as well as assisting women in need through her charitable donations.

Bra Finder
SIGN UP & GET $20 OFF YOUR FIRST ORDER!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.